Apr

2022

Jesus or Paul…

As victims of religious abuse, we become rather sensitive to how the bible is used and how it’s verses/doctrines/concepts are thrown around.

Let’s face it – the bible is used as a weapon far more than a tool for spreading unconditional love. We need to break down what we are dealing with, however, to get to grips with the reality of the bible.

First up, as a general concept, Christianity is entirely based on the teachings of Paul rather than Jesus. There’s a few reasons for this but basically (generalisation of course) Paul’s writings predate the gospels, so they became the doctrinal and theological foundations of the church. It was Paul’s writings, and those that fitted his theology, that were finally declared to be the inspired words of God by the Roman church around 400CE, and all other texts that presented anything different were literally destroyed (we’ve rediscovered a few of these over the centuries). This means that our entire belief system is built on the writings of a man who never met Jesus, and built his theology on visions – hardly a basis for a valid religion (despite the fact that most religions are actually based on the visions of some individuals, but that’s another story). This is why I prefer to call it “Paulianity”.

To complicate things, around half of the writings attributed to Paul were actually written by other people – something that most biblical historians now agree on.

So how much can we really trust that Paul knew what Jesus was on about? Sure, Christianity, as Paul created it, has been the most successful religion on the planet, but that doesn’t mean it’s based on anything factual.

So getting back to Jesus…

It’s now generally agreed that the biblical gospels were written at least 70 years after Jesus was said to have lived, possibly longer. None of the writers were eyewitnesses, and the names ascribed to each one are arbitrary and definitely not any of the disciples, as tradition would have us believe. The truth is, we have no idea what Jesus actually said – none whatsoever!

For starters, explain how his sermons and long complex prayers, often in the dark of night and on his own, were transcribed (accurately, word for word) by a scribe who followed him around with pen and parchment! Didn’t happen, I’m afraid.

These accounts are fabricated, possibly based on oral traditions. We just don’t know.

So… the problem is that the gospels don’t line up with Paul’s writings, despite the best efforts of theologians who create complex twisted doctrines to hobble it together.

For those of us who’ve been subject to biblical abuse around LGBT+ issues, we have had to figure out how to interpret Paul’s writings in relation to the apparent words of Jesus, that seem to express unconditional love far more than Paul – despite chapters like 1 Corinthians 13. If the bible was clear-cut and unambiguous, we wouldn’t be faced with these issues. But given the actual history of the bible, we really have nothing more than assumptions.

So, in all honesty and integrity, how do we approach all this? What do we believe? Do we give Paul the benefit of the doubt (given that his religion has been so successful), or do we put our faith in the writings that depict a very different Jesus, but were written much later by unknown sources? I also realise that the scriptures used in Paul’s writings to vilify LGBT+ people are incorrectly interpreted and translated, but that’s only the tip of the iceberg!

I present this, not to undermine our faith as such, but to be realistic about what we believe and why we believe it. The entire topic of LGBT+ people was a completely different mindset 2000 years ago, that we are trying to understand through the many surviving texts from the various cultures of the time. The biblical writers did not comprehend the issue in the same way we do at all.

Many LGBT+ Christians end up with a far simpler and more liberal approach to their beliefs, often claiming that they now have a simple relationship with Jesus. This is fair enough, given the mess that “biblical” Christianity really is. But when we realise that the only records we have about Jesus aren’t written by anyone who knew him, and the fact that it was physically impossible to capture the words of Jesus accurately, let alone verbatim, we are left to take a serious look at exactly what this relationship with Jesus really is.

If we accept the reality of Christian history, it may seem heretical and even terrifying, but we then become free to look at the deeper principles hidden in the biblical texts, knowing that they are metaphors, stories and myths, and we are free to use them in ways that actually bring love and unity to ourselves and the rest of humanity.

Mar

2022

Masturbation!

There, I said it!

MAS-TUR-BAY-SHUN

The big religious taboo!

It’s something most religions don’t talk about, unless some pastor gets brave enough to attempt biblical justification about why it’s so evil. And, usually, the gullible faithful swallow the botched biblical narrative presented by the only scripture that even comes close (pun intended).

We’re talking about Onan of course, who was the second son of Judah, slain by God as retribution for being “evil in the sight of the Lord” and disobeying a direct order from the Lord by being unwilling to father a child by his widowed sister-in-law, and “spilled his seed” on the ground.

Of course, the faithful fail to recognise that this text is NOT about masturbation. Rather, it’s all about God getting really pissed off when he pulls out of his sister-in-law before ejaculating, because of complex Levitical hereditary laws.

The truth is, masturbation is not mentioned anywhere in the bible – nowhere – zilch.

So why the big fuss? For some reason, European theologians decided it was completely disgusting in the 18th/19th centuries, and that mentality continued into most western cultures, and any other culture that was taken over by colonialism and infected with Christian missionaries.

Apart from that, masturbation has always been accepted as a normal/natural activity, especially as an alternative to getting someone pregnant. And yet it’s still something most “decent” people don’t want to talk about – perhaps because of the lingering effects of Victorian prudish attitudes, despite the fact that everyone does it.

Fortunately, medical/psychological professionals are united in extolling its benefits to all humans.

When kids hit puberty, there’s not a chance in hell you can stop them from enjoying this wonderful pastime (unless you happen to subscribe to toxic religious beliefs that you delight in inflicting on your children). So let them enjoy it. In fact, educate them about it!

It’s fun and healthy, so go for it!!

Mar

2022

Enough Already! (Cody’s story)

I’ve been a friend of Cody’s for a few years now, and stood alongside him through his extremely difficult journey of “coming out of religion”. Cody’s story is no ordinary one, however, and he has asked me to write and share it on his behalf.

Cody is a 50 year old trans man (assigned female at birth, identifies as male). He also has cerebral palsy (CP) and lives in an assisted living house with 24/7 care. He’s also adopted. His adoptive family are fundamentalist pentecostal Christians. He’s a survivor of sexual abuse, as a baby and on through childhood and as an adult. He suffered a range of physical and psychological abuses as a teenager in the care of Wilson Home in Auckland, and on into adult life. All of this created a “perfect storm” for serious mental health issues.

His journey, then, has been that of leaving abusive religion, facing a complete lack of love at any stage in his life, coming to terms with his gender identity, and finding who he really is, all exacerbated by his CP.

Although his adoptive parents had the best of intentions, and tirelessly provided for his physical wellbeing, they were incapable of providing him with the genuine, unconditional love he desperately needed as a young child and on through the rest of his life. The reasons for this are, of course, complex, but the most damaging has been the religious indoctrination present in the pentecostal church, which was echoed in his family life.

He was constantly made aware of his sinful nature, and as he grew he was pushed more and more to be “responsible” for sinful thoughts and actions in a way that constantly destroyed any sense of self-worth, which was pretty much non-existent from the start anyway.

He was sexually abused by an older adopted brother at the age of 12. His family did what they could to some extent, but much of the blame went on him and they eventually brushed it all under the carpet of family shame. This was the event that led them to placing him in full time care, to ostensibly give some space between him and his brother. His brother went on to be convicted of multiple rapes and has spent many years in prison.

This is just the tip of the iceberg though. Every aspect of his religious family upbringing dealt blow after blow of self loathing, inadequacy and failure, leading to behaviours that echo the desperate need for love that was never met – depression, anxiety, psychosis, self harm, suicide attempts, eating disorders… the fact that he’s survived this long is a testimony to his dogged resilience! But as you can imagine, the cost has been catastrophic.

He’s recently taken the massive step to walk away from church and renounce his faith, and to distance himself from his family. He’s decided that making a clean break is the only way to move forward. But this decision hasn’t come easily! To resist the indoctrination of a lifetime of fundamentalism, while still trying to maintain contact with the church community and friends, is impossible. Walking away from this, in reality, has taken a few years! So many attempts ended in giving in to the pressure, guilt and shame, returning to his abusers in a type of Stockholm Syndrome. The ongoing legacy of this religion will take time to unravel, as the layers of abuse are peeled away, but each layer removed allows love to enter.

So Cody is now free to start his life as a gay man! His dream is to begin physical transitioning, although he recognises the medical difficulties due to his disability.

His passion is to bring to light, the traumatic lives of LGBT+ people with disabilities – the complete lack of support in institutions, the ignorance of sexuality and gender issues within staff and clients, the bullying and shaming and the unwillingness of institutions to even acknowledge the sexual needs of those with disabilities in general. His other passion is helping those with Religious Trauma Syndrome.

You can join him on his journey on LinkedIn and Facebook

Nov

2021

The curse of sacrificial love

Give, give, give…
Sacrifice, sacrifice, sacrifice…

Always prefer others, put them first. Love is sacrificial, it doesn’t come naturally, we have to work on it.

In serving others we build our own self worth through our disciplined efforts.

If we truly want to make the world a better place we must exercise compassion and treat others with respect and dignity.

Self discipline is the only way to bring change to ourselves – we must watch our every thought and action…

Blah, blah, blah.

I call bullshit!

Until we truly love and embrace ourselves – fully and unconditionally – without judgement or expectation – simply realising that we are exactly as we should/could be – all our attempts to be better/loving/compassionate/caring etc, are just smoke and mirrors!

All that stuff about sacrificing and putting others first constantly represses and denies the very thing we are desperate for – the very thing we are trying to give to others, but deny ourselves – unconditional love!

We live in the vain subconscious hope that we will receive this if we focus on giving – more and more and more…

Or perhaps our self discipline will please our favourite deity so they will magically make us happy and provide the love we need by mystical osmosis.

George Bernard Shaw said “Self sacrifice enables us to sacrifice other people without blushing”. Ouch!

What are we really afraid of?

We think that the moment we start to give ourselves the attention we really need, we’ll become selfish, hedonistic and even narcissistic. After all, doesn’t the bible say that our hearts are corrupt and no one is capable of anything good? This insidious lie has crept through most of our cultures to the point where it’s completely accepted as the way it should be. So because of this, our only hope is to sacrifice our needs and to be humble, because God loves a humble heart. But despite our best efforts to convince ourselves otherwise, this is an endless cycle of self repression through fear. Yes FEAR!!

However, unless we stop the endless sacrifice, and love ourselves first and foremost, all our efforts are shallow and do nothing more than actually feed our “ego” – making us feel good, almost vicariously through our “humble” actions. We never actually change, we just get better at deluding ourselves.

Here’s something worth trying:
Love yourself in the same way you know others need to be loved.
Love yourself as you crave to be loved.
Embrace yourself as you would embrace a lover, who, when you look into their eyes, you only see their incredible worth and beauty.
Give to yourself as if you were the most stunningly amazing person you know.

When that happens – when the penny drops – when we see ourselves in that light – our love for others will naturally flow from us – without effort – like water from an endless river.

We are what we’ve been looking for.

NO external source – no God – no person – no thing – can substitute for this.

Imagine a world where we all know how wonderful we are, and see exactly the same wonder and beauty in everyone and everything else. No need to sacrifice anything. Does a river sacrifice anything to flow and nourish everything around it? When we see ourselves as this endless river of life and love, we can’t help but see everything else the same way.

But, but… you don’t know me, you don’t know how dreadful I really am. You don’t know how broken I am. You have no idea! I know beyond a doubt that I’m nothing but shit.

Who told you that? Why do you believe it? Seriously? Why? And who said you can’t be any different? Your God? Your family? Friends? Society? Church?

Try it. Face the fear and step past it. Look in the mirror and see that you are what you’ve always been looking for. Allow yourself to live loved!!

Aug

2021

Conversion Therapy – The Real Battle

(Although this blog is in regard to the passing of the anti-conversion therapy legislation currently happening in New Zealand, the issues are universal)

For those of us who have been through Conversion Therapy (CT), the issue is pretty clear – ban it!

But of course, the devil is in the detail, and boy are there some details!

Now I’m not really talking about the details of the legislation itself, although there are areas that need cleaning up and redefining etc. and there are others who have a really good handle on this.

I’m talking about far deeper implications and the paradigms that exist around the entire topic.

There are two main areas that CT can be addressed through – religious beliefs and human rights. There are cultural considerations, but they are mostly driven by these two foundations.

Human rights are reasonably obvious as most humans recognise our rights to “be who we are” within the constraints of inflicting harm on others.

But the religious aspect is an extremely large can of worms and the water can become very muddy when we try to use those worms to fish in the deep waters of religious beliefs. In fact, to do justice to the topic would require an entire book, so I’ll try to keep it specific.

Ultimately, it comes down to interpretation of the bible. After we peel away all the issues around religious freedom the whole thing hinges on “what does the bible say” and for most Christians, the bible appears to be very clear; being LGBT+ is wrong, and by wrong I mean anything from a sin that God can free us from to an abomination that God despises and condemns to hell.

For those of us who have done the hard work, we know that there is an entirely valid interpretation of scripture using concise exegetics and theology that completely reverse that interpretation. But for many Christians, they won’t even consider the possibility. So this is where the battle will always end up – always!!

We will get this bill passed, but the religious traditionalists will fight to the death to conserve their scriptures and will use whatever tactics they can to undermine the human rights aspects and morality of your average church goer/Christian, convinced they are doing God’s work.

This will be promoted through the new face of CT, where being LGBT+ is just another sin that a loving God will help us through. Or there’s the approach where it’s absolutely OK but we are called to celibacy. These approaches do have biblical support, and it would be foolish of us to think they don’t.

At the end of the day, we are faced with the difficult fact that the bible has, for as long as it’s been around, been interpreted in vastly conflicting ways. There are literally thousands of denominations, sects and cults, all claiming they alone have the true interpretation of scripture as revealed by God.

So we must chose our battles wisely. If you are addressing fundamentalists on biblical issues, make sure you know your stuff, because they do! Also be aware that they believe they are expressing God’s love for us by freeing us from sin. Far too often, I’ve seen well meaning LGBT+ folks attempting to present biblical arguments and only ending up looking foolish and actually reinforcing the views of the opposition. It’s often wiser to walk away.

We’ll win this battle, but the “war” is far from over.

Aug

2021

Pray Away – first impressions

I just watched the new Netflix movie Pray Away

I though I’d give some first impressions/reactions before taking some time to consider the deeper implications.

Very powerful, well produced, sensitive and respectful and yet very pointed in it’s premise.

As someone who spent 40 years of their life living this lie, I related to just about everything they presented. I was a desperate young man, looking to understand what was wrong with me and willing to try anything.

I even ended up became a leader in Living Waters, while still living a life of fear, shame and guilt, underscored by depression and suicide ideation. The movie presents this dynamic very intimately through the lives of a few of the key leaders of Exodus.

However, I don’t think it went anywhere near far enough into the complexities of this issue. But perhaps I feel that way because I’ve already worked through so much of it already. I guess the film could be viewed as a wake up call – an introduction that invites us to dig deeper.

For me, it wasn’t just reconciling my sexuality with my faith however. My faith was an integral part of everything I’d experienced, and clinging to Jesus was all that kept me alive. But the destruction ex-gay practices brought on my mind and life also directly affected my beliefs, to the point where they no longer had any validity. This film actually caused me to feel sad for those survivors who still cling to the faith that tried to destroy them. Of course, I know theologies and doctrines that successfully reconcile these issues, but the fact that this could even happen caused me to look outside the box of my dogmas and experiences.

So yeah, great film, and I know many will be inspired and set free by the bravery of those who spoke out. I think it will be a huge catalyst to freeing countless LGBT+ people, and exposing the doctrines of fundamentalist religion.

For me, its brought up some old wounds that need to be addressed, but its also inspired me to keep going deeper, and exposing the entire belief system that allows humans to be treated like this in the first place.

Jun

2021

The Mental Health Dilemma

I thought I’d have a go at doing video blogs!!

So here’s my very first, and hopefully not the last!

Here’s the transcript for your reading pleasure.

The mental health dilemma

“Mental health” has become one of the hottest topics in the world!

There’s little doubt that there are more suicides, greater rates of depression and related issues than any time in recorded history.

Our advances in psychiatry, neurology and related disciplines, has led the way to an incredible depth of understanding around how the mind works at every level. We are learning more about the mechanics of the brain almost daily.

We know for sure that the stresses of the modern world put pressures on us that we simply are not built to handle.

On the other hand, chronically stressful situations (trauma, abuse, war, disease etc) have been part of the human condition since day one, so it’s nothing new.

So are all our new understandings and treatments actually helping?

Good question! And I am yet to find any empirical research on this – assuming it’s even possible to research in the first place.

Personally, I’ve battled with mental health issues all my life – relating to being gay and having ADHD. But these specific issues (and countless others) have only been regarded as problems in more recent times.

There has always been LGBT+ people, and historically, it’s never been regarded as a mental health problem until the advent of psychiatry! Sure, it’s been treated in many weird and wonderful ways, but never in terms of a mental issue that had to be cured.

The same goes for ADHD, even more so! Historically, there were simply people who thought and interacted with the world differently. There wasn’t anything wrong with them, they were just different, usually more creative and eccentric, and were generally given the space to be what they were.

But now, we are so obsessed with creating “normal” people that we apply labels to anything that doesn’t fit this magical “normal” and then do everything we can to fix it.

In our efforts to understand, we’ve created an obsession. Those who don’t fit “normal” become fearful that our labels won’t allow us to function in society – that we’ll be rejected and alienated. We are encouraged to seek help that will somehow make our brains work the same as everyone else’s, building a background of shame that brings even more problems.

I’m not dissing modern psychology and neuro science at all. But I am saying that we’ve created an unreal and destructive precedent.

One of the single most important factors I’ve found when helping others (most notably with LGBT and Neuro-diverse issues) is letting them know they aren’t broken and don’t need fixing.

When this sinks in, it empowers us to make conscious decisions around how much we really want to fit in, and how much we want to simply be how we are, and let the rest of the world get used to it.

For me, finally accepting that I’m gay and that is absolutely OK, empowered me to find my niche – without having to fit into any stereotypes or expectations on either side of the issue.

The same for ADHD – it’s how my brain works. It’s wonderful and creative and allows me to see the world and life in a totally unique way. Once I accepted that (and all the implications) I was empowered to decide how much I wanted to be “normal” or whether it was fine to be me – gloriously eccentric, unorganised and creative, and let the rest of the world figure out how they should respond to that.

Of course, it’s a work in progress. I still succumb to performance anxiety, trying to meet other’s expectations. I catch myself procrastinating because of a deep sense of failure, after being told all my life I don’t do things the “right way”, which causes me to not even try.

But I’m getting better every day!

So my point is this.

Don’t get lost in the labels. Don’t allow fear and shame to drive you into a life of either constant failure and rejection, or an obsession with trying to fit in through endless therapy and drugs.

Despite all the amazing breakthroughs that mental health research has brought, we are still the masters of our own lives. We don’t have to “fit in” just because we’ve been told we have to.

Accept yourself. Be you – gloriously and messily you. And if you feel you need to seek help to function within our dysfunctional society, then that choice is yours – no on else’s!

Jun

2021

Silent Gays is growing!

I’m proud to announce our new email help service!

help@silentgays.com

Since starting Silent Gays a few years ago, I’ve mostly spent my time focussing on Facebook groups and messaging, but the reality is it’s a very limited audience and there is a huge need to reach those who don’t want to go on social media to look for help on religious abuse and conversion therapy issues. Privacy and discretion is hard to find on social media at the best of times, and this helps solve that problem!

The new email service is monitored by a small team of volunteers, each with their own areas of expertise, who have been through sexual orientation and gender identity change efforts, and have a passion to help others find a way through the mess.

I’ve also updated the website to focus around the CORE Book and Workbook. These have been the foundation of Silent Gays but have tended to get lost in the mix as it were. The books and the help email now have centre stage on the site.

Please take a few minutes to check out the site and grab a copy of the CORE book (digital formats only – no hardcopies, as yet). If you genuinely can’t afford it, let me know and I’ll send you a voucher for a free copy.

May

2021

Do your beliefs really work?

Does your belief system actually “work”?

Are your spiritual/religious beliefs genuinely beneficial to you, those around you and the rest of the world?

Have you ever stopped to assess this?

Do they bring you real peace and joy, not just “good feelings” or a sense of knowing the “real truth”, but seriously bring a depth that transforms your mental health, brings life and peace to those around you and empowers you to see every single human as unconditionally loved?

Do your beliefs empower you not to discriminate against others on the basis of their beliefs, race, gender or sexuality?

Do your beliefs genuinely transform your troubled mind, still the deep traumas, satisfy the grief, quieten the rage, relieve the depression or sooth the anxiety?

If you answered no, not really, not exactly… then you need to be brave enough to question them – seriously question them.

What do we want from our beliefs? Is there a better way?

Never be afraid to question everything!

May

2021

Too tired to engage

The only way to successfully communicate with fundamentalist Christians is through heart felt empathy – from our part. It seems this is the only way to find a crack in their armour, where they see our humanity, vulnerability and heart.

But I must confess, even then it’s an uphill battle.

Sadly for far too many, it’s too late for us to engage in any meaningful way. So many of us LGBT+ people have decided that we can no longer embrace our faith and are looking for safe spaces to deconstruct.

Many are too afraid to publicly admit that they no longer hold to the traditional Christian theology and doctrines, but remain because they have nowhere else to go!

The church community can be such a strong pull that to walk away feels like dying. They are suffering in a place of complete cognitive dissonance – the “silent gays” – hiding their true identity, living in fear, wearing the mask.

For many LGBT+ people struggling to maintain their faith, they are too tired. They are emotionally damaged to the point where the thought of engaging in the ways that require emotional vulnerability and compassion are just another load on top of what they already carry.

Although I personally try to engage traditionalists with empathy and compassion, I far too often find it exhausting and frustrating. I’m learning to walk away a little more graciously these days, but I have my moments!

This is a huge reality, and causes intense silent suffering. Mental health issues are inevitable and the suicide rate in LGBT+ Christians is horrifically high.

You aren’t alone! Don’t be afraid to reach out to those who have walked away from church. It’s OK to ask taboo questions. It’s OK to deconstruct in whatever way you need. “God” is far bigger than any religion can contain.

Jesus or Paul…

Masturbation!

Enough Already! (Cody’s story)

The curse of sacrificial love

I call bullshit!

What are we really afraid of?

Conversion Therapy – The Real Battle

Pray Away – first impressions

The Mental Health Dilemma

I thought I’d have a go at doing video blogs!!

The mental health dilemma

Silent Gays is growing!

I’m proud to announce our new email help service!

help@silentgays.com

Do your beliefs really work?

Too tired to engage

Latest blogs

The story behind Silent Gays

Pages